American Financial Group: Pay

American Financial Group paid its 6 named executives $34.9M in total in FY2025 (Dec). CEO Carl H. Lindner III was paid $11.0M of that.

PayNo stock prices for these years
CEO pay is from each proxy. The stock line is the value of $100 put in the stock at the start, from the price change of each fiscal year. Dividends are not in it.

Pay of each named executive

S. Craig LindnerCo-Chief Executive Officer (Co-Principal Executive Officer)
FY2025 (Dec)
FY2023 (Dec)
FY2022 (Dec)Not disclosed
FY2021 (Dec)Not disclosed
4 years
Carl H. Lindner IIICo-Chief Executive Officer (Co-Principal Executive Officer)
FY2025 (Dec)
FY2024 (Dec)
FY2023 (Dec)
FY2022 (Dec)Not disclosed
FY2021 (Dec)Not disclosed
5 years
John B. BerdingPresident of AFG and American Money Management
FY2025 (Dec)
FY2023 (Dec)
FY2022 (Dec)Not disclosed
FY2021 (Dec)Not disclosed
4 years
David L. Thompson, Jr.President and Chief Operating Officer of Great American Insurance Group
FY2025 (Dec)
FY2023 (Dec)
FY2022 (Dec)Not disclosed
3 years
Brian S. HertzmanSenior Vice President and Chief Financial Officer
FY2025 (Dec)
FY2023 (Dec)
FY2022 (Dec)Not disclosed
FY2021 (Dec)Not disclosed
4 years
Mark A. WeissSenior Vice President and General Counsel
FY2025 (Dec)
FY2024 (Dec)
FY2023 (Dec)
3 years

CEO pay against the pay peers

In FY2025 (Dec), the median CEO pay of the 10 peers with pay on file was $13.8M. CEO pay of American Financial Group for that year is not on file.

  1. 1Chubb
  2. 2Travelers Companies
  3. 3Hartford Insurance Group
  4. 4Assurant
  5. 5Arch Capital Group
  6. 6Renaissancere Holdings
  7. 7Hanover Insurance Group
  8. 8Axis Capital Holdings
  9. 9Rli
  10. 10Cincinnati Financial
  11. 11American Financial GroupNot disclosed
  12. 12CNA Financial Corp.Not disclosed
  13. 13Markel GroupNot disclosed
  14. 14Selective Insurance GroupNot disclosed
  15. 15W. R. Berkley CorporationNot disclosed

Pay of each named executive comes from the Summary Compensation Table of each proxy statement. Realized pay adds the value of options used and stock that vested. CEO pay of each peer comes from its own Pay versus Performance table.